Den moderata rationalismen: Kommentarer, preciseringar och kritik av några begrepp och teser som framlagts av Laurence Bonjour i dennes In Defense of Pure Reason
Independent thesis Basic level (degree of Bachelor), 10 points / 15 hpStudent thesis
The paper contains comment, clarification and criticism, even constructive criticism, of some theses that have been put forward by Laurence Bonjour in his In Defense of Pure Reason.
It presents a concept of experience that deals with the relation between cognizer and object of experience that has a great similarity to that of Bonjour. Through analysis it is shown that the concept of a priori entails that Bonjour has two concepts of a priori, a narrow and a broad one. The narrow one is, in my own words: According to moderate rationalism a proposition p is a priori justified if and only if you apprehend that p must be true in every possible world. This doesn’t mean that Bonjour doesn’t believe in an epistemological, metaphysical and semantic realm. The broad one does not mention anything about possible worlds.
Casullo in his A priori justification rejects Bonjour’s argument against Quine’s coherentism. A defense is put forward with the concept ‘an ideal of science for apparent rational insights’. The concept of axiomatic system and foundationalism is used. If we assume that the colour proposition ‘nothing can be red all over and green all over at the same time’ has the meaning that we, in this very moment, are representing a property in the world, thus we have an argument of superposition for the correctness of the proposition. The ground for this argumentation relies on the identification of colours with superposing electromagnetic waves.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Institutionen för religion och kultur , 2005. , 29 p.
A priori, a posteriori, superpose, red, blue, magenta, Bonjour, Kripke, Peano, justification, necessary, possible, analytic, synthetic, empiricism, rationalism, color
IdentifiersURN: urn:nbn:se:liu:diva-4543ISRN: LI-IRK/TFIL-C--05/002--SEOAI: oai:DiVA.org:liu-4543DiVA: diva2:20639