Bottom-up on-surface synthesis has emerged as a versatile tool to access and finely tune the electronic structure of nanographenes. The controlled generation of reactive intermediates catalyzed and stabilized by a supporting substrate has enabled the design, assembly, and characterization of a wide range of exotic tailor-made quantum materials. Even under these tightly controlled conditions, the growth of extended structures remains limited by termination processes and undesired side reactions. Here, we identify an H atom transfer as one principal contributor to the radical step growth termination that limits the on-surface growth of N = 7 armchair graphene nanoribbons (7-AGNRs) on Au(111) surfaces. Analysis of 7-AGNR lengths grown from protiated and deuterated molecular precursors reveals a primary kinetic isotope effect of KIE similar to 1.4. First-principles density functional theory calculations suggest that a concerted H atom transfer mechanism that involves the breaking of a C-H/D bond in the transition state is associated with radical chain termination.