Exergames (video games focused on physical exercise) can benefit from multiplayer collaboration, through an increased social element and increased enjoyment in the exercise regimen. To examine the different forms of collaboration, and how they impact both enjoyment and physical exertion, a game prototype was created and tested in two studies. Both studies compared two levels, one level with forced collaborative elements, and one level allowed for collaboration without explicitly forcing players to do so. The results occasionally indicate an increase in enjoyment for forced collaboration, but also an increase in physical exertion for implied collaboration. Both results are impacted by a bias towards test groups enjoying the later levels (as they have learned how to play the game by then), but the second study attempts to mitigate this by introducing a baseline level first. This thesis also highlights potential design issues for exergame puzzle games specifically.