Marriage is among the most fundamental social relationships undergirding the transmission of cultural norms and family property. How marital partnerships are formed is of considerable interestto a broad range of social scientists, particularly when and whetherpartners are sought from within the family or from the outside. Westudy the relatively high levels of cousin marriage characteristic ofEuropean settler families in the Cape Colony in the eighteenth andearly nineteenth centuries, using a unique linked data sample thatcombines marital choices with information on taxable wealth, andfrontier settlement. This permits us to test two common explana-tions for cousin marriage in the European demographic literature,a wealth-consolidation strategy versus a geographic isolationhypothesis. While we do find that parents of cousin marriageswere wealthier, we find no evidence of these marriages facilitatingdifferential wealth consolidation in the next generation, suggestingthat if this was a deliberate strategy to accumulate wealth, it wasnot a very successful one. Higher rates of cousin marriage in frontierareas suggest a role for geographic isolation.