The Value of Multi-Criteria Investing: An empirical study of how an investment strategy based on ROIC and complementary fundamental criteria performs relative to relevant benchmarks and Joel Greenblatt’s “Magic Formula” over time
2026 (English)Independent thesis Advanced level (degree of Master (One Year)), 20 credits / 30 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
This thesis examines how an investment strategy based on high Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) and complementary fundamental quality criteria performs relative to relevant benchmark indices and Joel Greenblatt’s “Magic Formula” over time. To do so, the study applies a quantitative and rule-based research design using historical point-in-time financial and market data for publicly traded common stocks in the U.S. and selected European markets between 2006 and 2026. The strategy is constructed through a screening and ranking framework based on profitability, financial stability, growth, and valuation. Portfolio performance is evaluated in terms of nominal return, alpha, Sharpe ratio, and Sortino ratio, and is compared against SPY, IMEU:NLD, and Greenblatt-based benchmark strategies.
The findings show that the ROIC-centered strategy outperformed the selected benchmark indices in both markets, although the results were substantially stronger in the U.S. market. The U.S. primary portfolio generated a cumulative nominal return of 2,386%, compared to 820% for SPY, while also producing higher risk-adjusted performance. The European primary portfolio also outperformed IMEU:NLD, but the degree of outperformance was more limited than in the U.S. market. Furthermore, the proposed strategy outperformed Joel Greenblatt’s “Magic Formula” in both markets, suggesting that the broader multi-criteria framework added investment value relative to a simpler profitability-and-valuation strategy. However, the supplementary tests indicate that added model complexity does not automatically improve performance, particularly in Europe where ROIC-focused modifications performed strongly. Taken together, this study suggests that investing based on fundamental information is not about identifying one perfect metric or a universally ideal combination of metrics, but about understanding how several imperfect signals can complement one another in a systematic investment process and be applied with discipline over time to create value.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2026. , p. 91
Keywords [en]
multi-criteria investing, fundamental information, ROIC, quality investing, value investing, “Magic Formula”, stock screening, abnormal returns, benchmark-relative outperformance, risk-adjusted performance, backtesting
National Category
Business Administration
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:liu:diva-225265ISRN: LIU-IEI-FIL-A--26/05103--SEOAI: oai:DiVA.org:liu-225265DiVA, id: diva2:2075468
Subject / course
Master Thesis in Business and Economics Programme (Business Administration)
Presentation
2026-06-04, C-huset, T19, Hans Meijers väg 16, Linköping, 09:30 (Swedish)
Supervisors
Examiners
2026-08-252026-06-182026-08-25Bibliographically approved